About This Blog

Ludwig von Mises (1881-1973) was the greatest economist of my time. His greatest works can be accessed here at no charge.

Mises believed that property, freedom and peace are and should be the hallmarks of a satisfying and prosperous society. I agree. Mises proved beyond a shadow of a doubt that the prospect for general and individual prosperity is maximized, indeed, is only possible, if the principle of private property reigns supreme. What's yours is yours. What's mine is mine. When the line between yours and mine is smudged, the door to conflict opens. Without freedom (individual liberty of action) the principle of private property is neutered and the free market, which is the child of property and freedom and the mother of prosperity and satisfaction, cannot exist. Peace is the goal of a prosperous and satisfying society of free individuals, not peace which is purchased by submission to the enemies of property and freedom, but peace which results from the unyielding defense of these principles against all who challenge them.

In this blog I measure American society against the metrics of property, freedom and peace.

Wednesday, December 28, 2011

Ron Paul And Anarchy, PART II

In my last post I described the fissure among "small 'L'" philosophical libertarians, some of whom consider themselves anarchists and others, minarchists. The debate between these two factions has always been intense and heated, and prior to the turn of the century the minarchists clearly, at least in my opinion, had the best of the argument.

The anarchists, known as anarcho-capitalists, were considered radical and impractical dreamers in search of a libertarian nirvana. They were really "out there," relying on the political experience of medieval Iceland to buttress their almost laughable point of view that anarchy once existed and that the free market is able to provide not only the best value in bread but also in law making. Yet, the two sides still communicated. That all changed on September 11, 2001.

After Islamists destroyed the twin towers of the World Trade Center, the libertarian debate between anarchists and minarchists seemed over for most, as both sides coalesced around their respective positions. The anarchists became more convinced than ever that statism precipitated the New York attack. Many felt that the US government organized the attack covertly. They thought the time for argument was over. They gradually excluded minarchist argument from the well respected website of the Ludwig von Mises Institute. The fledgling LewRockwell.com became the gathering place for the anarchist wing of the libertarian movement. LewRockwell, an ardent "anti-state anti-war pro-market" anarchist was the guiding force of both organizations. Moreover, websites which used to foster internecine anarchist/minarchist debate vanished from the web.

For their part, the libertarian minarchists went their own way as well. Many supported George W. Bush's aggressive response to 9/11. Some took positions in think tanks that were free market in their economic orientation, but supported secure US borders (anarchists favor open borders) and a somewhat interventionist US foreign policy. Some founded similarly aligned websites and blogs. The division between anarchists and minarchists had become institutional. If they existed at all, any continuing arguments between the two camps consisted of slurs and ridicule. Why? The fight began to pivot on questions regarding patriotism and genuine libertarianism, subjects that stir the emotions of American libertarians like few others.

One side, the anarchist faction, was convinced allegiance to the policies of George W. Bush was treasonous to the libertarian principle of non-aggression. The other side, the minarchist side, pointed out the nonsense of having open borders and an open immigration policy in a world full of crazed Islamist fundamentalists bent on terrorizing America. Many of these libertarians were even willing to give Bush's Iraq adventure the benefit of the doubt. Anarchists and minarchists alike thought that was nuts and un-libertarian. The fault lines in libertarianism grew wider, deeper and more diverse than ever.

Nowadays, in general, the anarchist libertarians are riding high while the minarchists are silently licking their wounds. Anarchists believe ten years of a tenuous, bloody and almost futile war in Iraq and Afghanistan vindicate their non-interventionist foreign policy philosophy. Moreover, they have simultaneously been able to co-opt the libertarian "free market" agenda as their own.

The fiscal and monetary crisis which occurred at the end of the Bush presidency convinced them more than ever before that government -- the huge bureaucracy, the Federal Reserve, Fannie and Freddie and the like -- is inherently destructive and evil. Of all libertarian and semi-libertarian opinion mills, the Ludwig von Mises Institute and LewRockwell.com were two of the few that steadfastly opposed government bailouts of the economy. Their fervent anti-war and unflinching pro-market positions gradually melded into the anti-state rhetoric which is so popular these days on campuses and on the internet.

Today it is virtually impossible for minarchists to get a word in edgewise much less gain a philosophical foothold. Any attempt to do so is immediately slandered as the hated and mystical neo-conservatism.

This is not to say all is quiet on the Western front among the anarchists. Today most anarcho-capitalists, especially those who have not gone apolitical or anti-political, prefer calling themselves "Voluntaryists." They apparently want to disassociate themselves from the bad connotations of the word anarchism, which tend to conjure up images of freaks tossing Molotov cocktails through department store windows in places like Seattle. Such images are counterproductive to winning hearts and minds in actual, real political campaigning.

My mention of apolitical or anti-political anarcho-capitalists was not accidental. It seems the latest schism in the libertarian faith is the divide between voluntaryists, who seek to establish a libertarian nirvana in the US by means of political action within the system, and fundamentalist anarchists who believe running for political office and even voting is statist aggression. These fundamentalist anarchists, who I will refer to, in the interests of clarity, as the all-in anarchists, are the true problem children of the libertarian anarchist movement. Let me explain.

The crux of the anarchist argument against minarchism is that anarchism is the logical extension of the first principles of libertarianism: first, the famed non-aggression principle; and second, the principle of self-ownership. According to Wikipedia, the non-aggression principle “asserts that aggression is inherently illegitimate. Aggression…is defined as the initiation or threatening of violence against a person or legitimately owned property of another.” Wikipedia says self-ownership “is the concept of property in one's own person, expressed as the moral or natural right of a person to be the exclusive controller of his own body and life.”

Since almost by definition "government," or the "state," is in the business of coercing individuals to act in a particular way and forcing individuals to forfeit their property to the state by means of taxation, anarchy—the absence of government—is held by its advocates to be most logically consistent with libertarianism. However, one needn’t be a logician to see the contradiction in a voluntaryist, who believes in the absence of government but, at the same time, runs for political office. Voluntaryists rationalize their political action by arguing that one may be active in politics in order to ultimately eliminate the need for politics.

The all-in anarchists are quick to point out that such a position is merely pragmatic and strictly illogical. Ultimately, logic dictates that, if the state is in the business of aggression against person and property, then becoming part of the state through political action is aggression as well. Thus, all-in anarchism is THE ultimate and logical extension of the prime libertarian directives.

This is the kind of esoteric, internecine argument that takes place nowadays on websites like LewRockwell.com and the Ludwig von Mises Institute: Which faction of anarchism is genuinely libertarian? Any mention of minarchism has passed by the wayside.

What does all this have to do with Ron Paul and his run for the Presidency in 2012?

Plenty!

Ron Paul comes from the Voluntaryist wing of libertarian anarchism.

(Believe it or not, Paul’s candidacy is criticized and opposed by doctrinaire all-in anarchists like Stephan Molyneaux. Molyneaux’s archive of articles has apparently been purged by LewRockwell.com which supports Paul’s run for the Presidency.)

I don't think Paul’s status as a voluntaryist anarchist is debatable. It certainly seems like a settled fact among Paul's political supporters.

Consider this video...


Paul may disavow his controversial newsletters of 25 years ago by saying he took a hands-off approach to publishing them, and that he disagrees with the iconoclastic rhetoric and political positions in them, but the fact remains he allowed two aggressive and confirmed voluntaryist anarchists virtual free rein to produce and write the newsletters: Lew Rockwell and Jeffrey Tucker. Now Paul is suffering the political damage that Rockwell, Tucker and anarchist political theory have rained down on him.

Deservedly or not, Paul is being tarred and feathered by the company he kept and continues to keep.

Don't misinterpret what I am saying. Yes, I believe Ron Paul is both emotionally and intellectually a “voluntaryist" anarchist. I believe he participates in politics because he does not want to reform the Washington power structure, but wants to make it completely obsolete. In short, he wants to eliminate government by political means and, thereby, avoid a violent revolution. If Ron Paul is anything, he is committed to non-violence.

I am a minarchist. Yet, I support Ron Paul for President. I support his candidacy not because of his voluntaryist anarchist beliefs, but in spite of them. I’ll try to explain why as I continue this series of posts. First, however, I want to explore the damage being done to Ron Paul’s credibility and to his campaign by the likes of Lew Rockwell and company, along with the outrageous political philosophy of voluntaryism.

More to follow.

839 comments:

1 – 200 of 839   Newer›   Newest»
theCL said...

A few thoughts ...

Paul is a minarchist of the Robert A Taft school of American conservatism. Libertarian by today's standards for sure, but Ron Paul is no anarchist.

The minarchist argument is alive and well at both LewRockwell.com and Mises.org.

Anarcho-capitalists are not necessarily voluntarists, and vice versa.

Joseph Sobran, a man who's conservative bonafides are undeniable, found himself too to be a "Reluctant Anarchist." My point being that it's not as radical as you seem to think.

Open borders? You obviously haven't read anarcho-capitalist titans Murray Rothbard and Hans-Hermann Hoppe.

Paul's libertarian problem comes from left-libertarians and beltway libertarians (cosmotarians/liberaltarians), not anarcho-capitalists.

What do you have against Jeffrey Tucker?

Anarcho-capitalism is rooted in the natural law theory of St. Thomas Aquinas, the very religious, legal and political traditions America was founded upon, and that man fought centuries to achieve.

Ancient Israel (see Judges, Samuel, etc.) had a societal structure not unlike anarcho-capitalism. When they demanded a king (ruler(s)), God declared it a rejection of Him.

And yes, any way you slice it, taxation is theft. Of course, this wasn't a controversial statement in America half a century ago either. Boy, how times have changed.

Sherman Broder said...

Thanks for your thoughts, CL.

First of all, my posts are written directly from my own experience. I do not intend that they be viewed as any kind of overall, objective or absolute history of libertarianism. I am not an "insider." I have no axe to grind. I'm happy to accept corrections and other points of view from those more in the know.

Second, mine is a layman's prospective. I don't profess to be an expert on the fine political or philosophical distinctions between voluntarism, anarcho-capitalism and various shades of libertarianism. I call things as I subjectively understand them.

Third, I'm trying to frame these posts in the overall, broad context of anarchism vs minarchism, i.e., no government vs limited government.

Fourth, I've read some Rothbard and Hoppe, but I am certainly not a scholar with regard to libertarian authors. Recently, I've not even followed LewRockwell.com or LVMI on a daily basis.

That said, I'll try to answer your questions.

It may be obvious to you that Ron Paul is for limited government. Based on his words and actions -- and his longtime associations, such as with Lew Rockwell -- my opinion is that he views limited government as a means to an end, the end being a society with no government. If you can point me to something Paul has written that contradicts this opinion, I'll change it. I think we can both agree that on the scale of minarchism to anarchism, Paul is about as close to anarchism as an alleged minarchist can get.

My comment regarding open borders was based on the platform of the Libertarian Party which called for open borders the last time I looked. I don't believe Lew Rockwell believes in closed borders. Again, if I'm mistaken, I'll change my mind. However, I do appreciate the point of view of Rothbard and Hoppe.

I have nothing against Jeffrey Tucker. In fact, I have nothing against Lew Rockwell or any libertarian. Moreover, I admire Rockwell and Tucker for the work they've done at LVMI in the service of Austrian economics.

However, I have a huge problem with the anarcho-capitalist argument. I believe its premise is false and its logic is faulty. I understand why there is an anarchist bias at LVMI, though I dislike it. My opinion is that the anarchist argument polarizes the economic and political discussion. This harms Paul's political efforts and the political efforts of non-anarchist libertarians.

Finally, I appreciate the roots of the anarchist premise. I merely think that the roots are buried in barren soil.

As regards to taxation being "theft," I hope to post my complete thoughts on that subject sometime soon. In short, I believe taxation is theft in a dictatorial state, but, strictly speaking, it cannot be considered theft in the context of a consensual society. (Whether the USA remains a consensual society is a matter for further discussion.)

Thanks again for you input. I truly appreciate the point of view.

Anonymous said...

best online casinos [url=http://onlinecasinouse.com/# ]casino real money [/url] online casinos online slots free casino slot games

Anonymous said...

best free slots vegas world [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]free online slots games [/url] brian christopher slots free slots vegas usa no deposit casino bonus codes

Anonymous said...

free slot machine games zone casino vegas world online casino games free royal river casino

Anonymous said...

online casino gambling real money casino real casino play free lucky 777 slots

Anonymous said...

play lady luck online [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]hollywood casino [/url] penny slots free free online slots vegas world

Anonymous said...

free slots with bonus rounds no download [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]caesars casino online [/url] download free casino slot games paradise casino

Anonymous said...

slots free http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# tropicana online casino free slots machines casino real money

Anonymous said...

caesar casino free slots games [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]vegas world free slots games [/url] usa online casino slot machines casino free

Anonymous said...

http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# hollywood casino free online slots games casino games online slots lounge

Anonymous said...

http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# slots for real money vegas casino games slots free all free casino slots games free slots casino games

Anonymous said...

vegas casino online [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]no deposit bonus codes for usa players [/url] free vegas slots online casino play free casino slots now

Anonymous said...

play online casino games [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]hollywood casino online slots free [/url] prairie meadows casino high 5 casino free online slots no download

Anonymous said...

show all free slots games [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]penny slots for free online [/url] play blackjack for free free 777 slots no download

Anonymous said...

free slots no download casinos near my location online casinos 300 free slots no download no registration

Anonymous said...

200 free slot games [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]penny slots free [/url] win free money no deposit lady luck online casino

Anonymous said...

slots free online heart of vegas slots slot machines for home entertainment plainridge casino

Anonymous said...

penny slots free online http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# free games online no download no registration myvegas slots free slot games download full version

Anonymous said...

buffalo gold slots cashman casino slots free pop slots casino all free casino slots

Anonymous said...

free games for casino slots hollywood http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# free casino blackjack vegas slots casino best casino slot games

Anonymous said...

online casino slots [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]poker games [/url] free casino slots games hollywood online casino

Anonymous said...

http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# igt free slots real casino slots vegas world free slots games casino games free slots

Anonymous said...

heart of vegas free slots [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]free online slots no download no registration [/url] online slot games free casino casino free

Anonymous said...

free penny slots with bonus spins [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]posh casino online [/url] free las vegas slot machines royal river casino

Anonymous said...

lady luck casino vicksburg [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]scatter slots [/url] free slot play no download vegas world free slots games foxwoods online casino

Anonymous said...

free online bingo vegas world [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]world class casino slots [/url] free games for casino slots hollywood play free vegas casino games

Anonymous said...

msn games zone online casino [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]play lady luck [/url] hollywood slots free las vegas casino games online casino reviews

Anonymous said...

real money casinos vegas world free slots games slotomania on facebook wizard of oz slots

Anonymous said...

http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# bonus casino free slots vegas casino slots free bovada casino

Anonymous said...

play slots online http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# big fish casino free online free casino games online royal river casino

Anonymous said...

lady luck casino free games free slots with no download or registration hollywood casino free slots online best time to play slot machines

Anonymous said...

paradise casino [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]vegas world free games [/url] hollywood casino online slots free brian christopher slots

Anonymous said...

hollywood casino play4fun http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# casino games free online games that pay real money free casino games online

Anonymous said...

http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# vegas world slots las vegas free slots free slots no registration vegas casino free online games

Anonymous said...

http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# free slots no download no registration free slot games online cashman casino slots vegas casino games slots free

Anonymous said...

slots online free [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]heart of vegas slots [/url] casino games slots free rock n cash casino slots mgm online casino

Anonymous said...

100 no deposit bonus codes [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]zone online casino games [/url] 100 best usa casinos with best codes casino slot free slots hollywood

Anonymous said...

paradise casino old version vegas world penny slots free online online slots free

Anonymous said...

list of online casinos for us players house of fun slots vegas slots online free free coins slotomania

Anonymous said...

no download no registration slots http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# show all free slots games foxwoods casino online all casino games free download

Anonymous said...

free casino blackjack games http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# connect to vegas world play online casino cashman casino slots

Anonymous said...

gamepoint slots [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]penny slots free online [/url] empire city casino online free cashman casino slots

Anonymous said...

all free casino slots http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# slotomania free online slots game casinos near me free penny slots online

Anonymous said...

lady luck online casino http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# jackpot party casino slots online casinos online casino

Anonymous said...

cashman casino slots online gambling casino slots play casino

Anonymous said...

http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# world class casino slots [url=http://nodepositcasinoww.com/# ]big fish casino [/url] slots for real money

Anonymous said...

big fish casino slots free slots games free online casino slots

Anonymous said...

casino game play casino slots games casino game

Anonymous said...

http://casinogamesww.com/# online slots slots for real money real casino slots world class casino slots

Anonymous said...

online slots http://casinobonuscodesww.com/# casino bonus codes free casino slot games free slots

Anonymous said...

http://casinorealmoneyiw.com/# online slots best online casino slots for real money casino real money

Anonymous said...

slot games [url=http://casinoslotsww.com/# ]big fish casino [/url] casino slots slots online

Anonymous said...

http://playcasinoww.com/# vegas casino slots casino blackjack vegas casino slots online slot games

Anonymous said...

no deposit casino http://casinoslotsww.com/# world class casino slots slots online online slot games

Anonymous said...

http://onlinecasinowps.com/# casino blackjack [url=http://casinoslotsnse.com/# ]big fish casino [/url] best online casinos

Anonymous said...

online casino bonus [url=http://freecasinogamesww.com/# ]slot games [/url] slots games casino bonus codes real money casino

Anonymous said...

http://casinoslotsww.com/# slots free [url=http://casinogamesmn.com/# ]casino real money [/url] online slots

Anonymous said...

online casino bonus http://casinogamesww.com/# vegas casino slots casino slots free casino

Anonymous said...

free slots games http://casinorealmoneyiw.com/# cashman casino slots free casino slot games world class casino slots

Anonymous said...

http://casinoslotsnse.com/# online slot games [url=http://bestcasinoww.com/# ]cashman casino slots [/url] gold fish casino slots

Anonymous said...

free slots [url=http://casinogamesww.com/# ]casino game [/url] play slots online slots

Anonymous said...

http://casinoslotsww.com/# gold fish casino slots [url=http://casinoslotsnse.com/# ]slots online [/url] best online casinos

Anonymous said...

http://casinogamesmn.com/# online casino slots vegas slots online casino blackjack big fish casino

Anonymous said...

slots games [url=http://casinoslotsww.com/# ]online casino gambling [/url] big fish casino cashman casino slots

Anonymous said...

casino games [url=http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# ]play casino [/url] online casino online casino slots online casino games

Anonymous said...

slots for real money [url=http://playcasinoww.com/# ]free casino games online [/url] play slots casino games casino online slots

Anonymous said...

online slot games gold fish casino slots play slots casino blackjack

Anonymous said...

play online casino http://casinoonlineslotsww.com/# free casino slot games real casino slots online gambling

Anonymous said...

slots free http://casinoonlineww.com/# online casino gambling free casino slot games slot games

Anonymous said...

play casino real money casino casino online best online casino

Anonymous said...

casino games http://freecasinogamesww.com/# online casino cashman casino slots gold fish casino slots

Anonymous said...

play casino online casino gambling casino bonus codes no deposit casino

Anonymous said...

casino online slots real casino slots play slots online vegas casino slots

Anonymous said...

best online casinos [url=http://casinogamesejk.com/# ]casino games [/url] online gambling slots games

Anonymous said...

casino real money online slots real casino slots free slots games

Anonymous said...

casino slots [url=http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# ]casino bonus codes [/url] online casino real money slots free gold fish casino slots

Anonymous said...

no deposit casino [url=http://bestcasinoww.com/# ]free casino [/url] vegas slots online casino games

Anonymous said...

vegas casino slots http://casinorealmoneyiw.com/# best online casino online casino gambling free casino slot games

Anonymous said...

http://casinogamesejk.com/# casino games online casino bonus free casino games online big fish casino

Anonymous said...

slots online [url=http://freecasinogamesww.com/# ]online casino [/url] casino play play casino free casino games

Anonymous said...

http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# free casino slot games online slot games casino play casino play

Anonymous said...

real casino slots free casino games slots free world class casino slots

Anonymous said...

world class casino slots [url=http://casinoslotsnse.com/# ]slots online [/url] online casino bonus slots games

Anonymous said...

http://casinogameww.com/# free casino games [url=http://casinorealmoneyiw.com/# ]slots games [/url] slot games

Anonymous said...

http://casinogamesmn.com/# online casino games online casino games online casino slots best online casinos

Anonymous said...

http://casinoonlineww.com/# free slots games best online casinos casino slots real money casino

Anonymous said...

casino bonus codes vegas casino slots casino slots online casino games

Anonymous said...

online casinos [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]gold fish casino slots [/url] online gambling online slots free casino slot games

Anonymous said...

real casino slots http://nodepositcasinoww.com/# online gambling free slots online slot games

Anonymous said...

http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# slot games [url=http://casinogamesww.com/# ]online casino gambling [/url] slots free

Anonymous said...

casino online free slots games real money casino real money casino

Anonymous said...

play casino [url=http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# ]free casino games [/url] online casino bonus free slots play slots

Anonymous said...

casino play http://casinoonlineww.com/# online casinos casino slots casino game

Anonymous said...

http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# casino game [url=http://casinorealmoneyiw.com/# ]best online casino [/url] vegas slots online

Anonymous said...

free casino slot games [url=http://freecasinogamesww.com/# ]online casino real money [/url] free casino games online slot games

Anonymous said...

no deposit casino [url=http://casinobonuscodesww.com/# ]play slots [/url] real casino slots online casino slots online casino

Anonymous said...

http://casinorealmoneyiw.com/# online casino bonus [url=http://freecasinogamesww.com/# ]slots games free [/url] free slots games

Anonymous said...

http://casinorealmoneyiw.com/# casino bonus codes casino slots casino games online slots

Anonymous said...

gold fish casino slots [url=http://casinoslotsww.com/# ]online casino real money [/url] online casino casino play world class casino slots

Anonymous said...

casino games [url=http://casinoslotsww.com/# ]slots online [/url] online casino real money no deposit casino

Anonymous said...

free slots games [url=http://casinogamesww.com/# ]casino blackjack [/url] free casino games online real money casino

Anonymous said...

free online slots http://nodepositcasinoww.com/# slots games play slots casino real money

Anonymous said...

http://casinoslotsnse.com/# free casino games [url=http://playcasinoww.com/# ]free casino games [/url] online casino games

Anonymous said...

online slot games [url=http://bestcasinoww.com/# ]free casino slot games [/url] online casino bonus casino game

Anonymous said...

http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# free casino real casino slots play casino online casinos

Anonymous said...

casino bonus codes big fish casino free online slots free casino games

Anonymous said...

online casino bonus [url=http://casinorealmoneyiw.com/# ]best online casinos [/url] slots games casino real money online casino bonus

Anonymous said...

vegas casino slots [url=http://casinogamesmn.com/# ]online slots [/url] play slots online cashman casino slots

Anonymous said...

http://freeonlinecasinoslotsww.com/# vegas casino slots [url=http://casinobonuscodesww.com/# ]best online casino [/url] real money casino

Anonymous said...

online slot games http://casinogameww.com/# play casino casino real money free casino games online

Anonymous said...

online casino real money big fish casino world class casino slots no deposit casino

Anonymous said...

play online casino [url=http://playcasinoww.com/# ]slots free [/url] gold fish casino slots casino games

Anonymous said...

real money casino [url=http://playcasinoww.com/# ]casino games [/url] free slots games world class casino slots

Anonymous said...

slots free [url=http://casinoonlineww.com/# ]online casinos [/url] casino slots play online casino best online casino

Anonymous said...

slots free [url=http://freecasinogamesww.com/# ]free slots [/url] casino games free casino slot games

Anonymous said...

vegas slots online [url=http://onlinecasinowps.com/# ]play slots [/url] slot games casino online

Anonymous said...

http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# slot games [url=http://casinoslotsww.com/# ]slots for real money [/url] casino play

Anonymous said...

vegas slots online [url=http://nodepositcasinoww.com/# ]slots for real money [/url] slots games free slots casino bonus codes

Anonymous said...

http://casinogamesww.com/# slots games free cashman casino slots slots games casino blackjack

Anonymous said...

http://casinoonlineww.com/# free casino slot games [url=http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# ]play casino [/url] real money casino

Anonymous said...

casino blackjack [url=http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# ]slot games [/url] free casino slot games online gambling play slots

Anonymous said...

best online casinos [url=http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# ]slots free [/url] free casino games casino blackjack play online casino

Anonymous said...

free casino slot games http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# slots games casino slots real casino slots

Anonymous said...

http://casinoonlineslotsww.com/# play slots [url=http://freecasinogamesww.com/# ]play slots online [/url] gold fish casino slots

Anonymous said...

http://casinorealmoneyeyu.com/# big fish casino no deposit casino free slots free online slots

Anonymous said...

http://freeonlinecasinoslotsww.com/# gold fish casino slots [url=http://onlinecasinogamesww.com/# ]cashman casino slots [/url] casino slots

Anonymous said...

http://casinogamesmn.com/# online slot games play online casino slots free slots games free

Anonymous said...

credit score scale [url=http://freecreditscoreses.com/ ]score credit [/url] check your credit score credit rating check

Anonymous said...

credit bureaus how to get credit report checking credit score credit report

Anonymous said...

mortgage credit report [url=https://freecreditscoreses.com/ ]fico credit score [/url] credit check best credit score what is a credit report

Anonymous said...

how to unfreeze credit report [url=https://getcreditscorefast.com/ ]how to improve your credit score [/url] free credit report canada yearly free credit report

Anonymous said...

what is a great credit score [url=https://creditreportms.com/ ]credit karma free credit score [/url] find credit score credit score companies

Anonymous said...

free credit score check your credit report online [url=https://freecreditscoreses.com/ ]free annual credit report free [/url] average credit score free credit score erian

Anonymous said...

free credit report online https://creditreportms.com/ government free credit report how to get a free credit report what is a good credit score number

Anonymous said...

how to raise credit score free credit report and scores credit karma ck my credit score free credit report gov

Anonymous said...

freeze credit report [url=https://creditreportl.com/ ]check credit score for free [/url] what is a credit score how to dispute credit report items checking credit score

Anonymous said...

check my credit score [url=https://getcreditscorefast.com/ ]how to get a credit score [/url] how to credit score what is an excellent credit score

Anonymous said...

business credit report how to get a credit report credit rating check check free credit score

Anonymous said...

https://creditscorecheckresults.com/ annual free credit report what is a good credit score number good credit score range high credit score

Anonymous said...

transunion credit report [url=https://freecreditscoreses.com/ ]transunion credit report dispute [/url] karma free credit score credit report monitor free credit

Anonymous said...

myfreecreditreport [url=https://getcreditscorefast.com/ ]how to check credit score [/url] how do i check my credit score highest credit score possible

Anonymous said...

https://creditscorecheckresults.com/ get a credit report annualcreditreport free credit report how to get free credit report

Anonymous said...

yearly free credit report https://creditscoresrw.com/ mortgage credit report check free credit score free credit report experian

Anonymous said...

https://creditreportadvanced.com/ good credit score annual credit report free best credit score free credit score check your credit report online

Anonymous said...

credit score needed for mortgage [url=https://creditscoreblk.com/ ]social credit score [/url] my free credit report annual credit score ratings

Anonymous said...

https://creditscoresmy.com/ free credit ck credit bureau experian free credit score check your credit rating

Anonymous said...

check my credit score credit karma [url=https://freecreditscoreses.com/ ]get credit report - free credit report [/url] credit karma ck my credit score annual credit report completely free government

Anonymous said...

https://creditreportms.com/ credit report free annual credit report free check credit scores credit score ranges

Anonymous said...

my free credit report annual [url=https://creditscorecheckresults.com/ ]credit karma ck my credit score [/url] free credit score credit report how to get a free credit report

Anonymous said...

credit karma free credit report [url=https://freecreditscoreses.com/ ]how to increase credit score [/url] freecreditreport my free credit score

Anonymous said...

excellent credit score https://creditreportl.com/ one time free credit score how to read credit report free credit card

Anonymous said...

free credit report info [url=https://creditreportms.com/ ]business credit score [/url] free yearly credit report credit score needed for mortgage

Anonymous said...

https://creditscorecheckresults.com/ transunion credit report phone number annual credit report completely free experian how to dispute credit report items credit karma free credit score

Anonymous said...

unfreeze credit report https://creditscoresbureau.com/ free credit report and scores freecreditreport credit karma com free credit score

Anonymous said...

https://creditscoreblk.com/ credit karma ck my credit score how do i check my credit score free transunion credit report equifax free credit report

Anonymous said...

check credit report [url=https://creditscoresmy.com/ ]free equifax credit report [/url] free credit score karma check my credit score for free

Anonymous said...

get my free credit report [url=https://getcreditscorefast.com/ ]equifax credit report [/url] freecreditscore how to improve credit score

Anonymous said...

free credit score equifax [url=https://creditreportl.com/ ]transunion free credit report online [/url] annual credit report what is an excellent credit score

Anonymous said...

https://creditreportms.com/ free credit scores without paying absolutely credit free score how to check your credit score what is good credit score

Anonymous said...

credit score companies [url=https://getcreditscorefast.com/ ]annual credit report completely free experian [/url] annual credit report how to get free credit report

Anonymous said...

check credit score for free full credit report how to increase credit score karma credit score

Anonymous said...

chase credit score https://creditscorecheckresults.com/ view my credit report how to dispute credit report items get credit report

Anonymous said...

annual credit report [url=https://getcreditreportstats.com/ ]annual credit report completely free government [/url] full credit report credit karma uk credit report companies

Anonymous said...

https://creditreportgetstats.com/ free annual credit report complaints my credit score free annual credit report free annual credit report government official

Anonymous said...

view my credit report [url=https://creditscoreblk.com/ ]experian credit [/url] experian free credit score free credit score erian

Anonymous said...

https://creditscoresrw.com/ my credit scoring free credit report canada free credit transunion free credit report online

Anonymous said...

anual credit report [url=https://getcreditscorefast.com/ ]experian business credit report [/url] credit karma equifax free credit report experian free credit report

Anonymous said...

free credit report instant how to get free credit report credit karma uk get credit report - free credit report

Anonymous said...

highest credit score possible [url=https://creditscorecheckresults.com/ ]free credit score check online credit report [/url] how to check my credit score free credit score experian my credit score

Anonymous said...

how to check my credit score [url=https://creditscoreblk.com/ ]score credit [/url] get credit report - free credit report truly free credit report

Anonymous said...

annual free credit report official site [url=https://creditscoresbureau.com/ ]what credit score for mortgage [/url] how to credit score how to check credit score for free

Anonymous said...

yearly free credit report https://creditscoresrw.com/ how to get credit report check your credit report how to credit score

Anonymous said...

check credit report myfreecreditreport max credit score how to increase credit score

Anonymous said...

business credit score [url=https://getcreditscorefast.com/ ]check your credit rating [/url] credit bureau credit score ranges

Anonymous said...

my free credit report credit score repair get my credit score truly free credit scores

Anonymous said...

average credit score credit score online credit reports excellent credit score

Anonymous said...

get my credit score [url=https://creditreportadvanced.com/ ]free credit score check online credit report [/url] best credit score how to credit score karma credit score

Anonymous said...

credit karma free credit score how to credit score how to unfreeze credit report experian credit

Anonymous said...

https://creditscoreblk.com/ experian credit credit score ratings chart credit scoring transunion free credit report

Anonymous said...

annual free credit report [url=https://getcreditreportstats.com/ ]absolutely free credit report [/url] how to dispute credit report items equifax free credit score how to dispute credit report

Anonymous said...

https://creditreportgetstats.com/ how to ck credit score how do i check my credit score experian credit report truly free credit scores

Anonymous said...

credit reports [url=https://creditscoresmob.com/ ]what is a credit score [/url] credit scores online one time free credit score https://creditscoresmob.com/

Anonymous said...

credit score repair [url=https://creditscoresmob.com/ ]get free credit score [/url] trans union corporation free credit report free annual credit report free credit scores

Anonymous said...

https://creditreportms.com/ whats my credit score how to ck credit score chase credit good credit score range

Anonymous said...

business credit report experian free credit report free credit report government free credit scores

Anonymous said...

credit reports https://creditscoreblk.com/ free credit score check check your credit report truly free credit report

Anonymous said...

credit scores free credit report how to credit score consumer credit report https://creditreportadvanced.com/

Anonymous said...

https://creditscoresmy.com/ annual free credit score free credit score experian how to check credit score how to ck my credit score

Anonymous said...

credit score companies check credit score for free equifax credit report credit karma credit score

Anonymous said...

how to get credit report [url=https://creditscoresrw.com/ ]annual credit report request form [/url] free credit score credit report transunion free credit report free credit score equifax

Anonymous said...

free credit score report https://creditreportadvanced.com/ free credit score ck free credit score ck my credit score

Anonymous said...

https://creditscoresbureau.com/ cheapest credit report free annual credit report complaints credit scores free credit report info

Anonymous said...

https://getcreditreportstats.com/ get my credit report view my credit report free credit score karma free credit karma

Anonymous said...

freecreditscore [url=https://freecreditreportstats.com/ ]free credit report and scores [/url] transunion free credit report online get a free credit report yearly free credit report

Anonymous said...

my credit report https://freecreditreportstats.com/ how to improve credit score get a free credit report free credit score free credit reports

Anonymous said...

free credit score check online credit report [url=https://getcreditreportstats.com/ ]find my credit score [/url] what is credit score absolutely free credit report cheapest credit report

Anonymous said...

boost my credit score [url=https://getcreditscorefast.com/ ]what is credit score [/url] my free credit report credit check free

Anonymous said...

boost credit score https://freecreditscoreses.com/ how do i check my credit score freecreditreport credit score rating

Anonymous said...

credit score free [url=https://creditscoreblk.com/ ]karma credit score [/url] check credit score check my credit score equifax free credit score

«Oldest ‹Older   1 – 200 of 839   Newer› Newest»